-
ACM MMSys 2024 Bandwidth Estimation in Real Time Communications Challenge
Authors:
Sami Khairy,
Gabriel Mittag,
Vishak Gopal,
Francis Y. Yan,
Zhixiong Niu,
Ezra Ameri,
Scott Inglis,
Mehrsa Golestaneh,
Ross Cutler
Abstract:
The quality of experience (QoE) delivered by video conferencing systems to end users depends in part on correctly estimating the capacity of the bottleneck link between the sender and the receiver over time. Bandwidth estimation for real-time communications (RTC) remains a significant challenge, primarily due to the continuously evolving heterogeneous network architectures and technologies. From t…
▽ More
The quality of experience (QoE) delivered by video conferencing systems to end users depends in part on correctly estimating the capacity of the bottleneck link between the sender and the receiver over time. Bandwidth estimation for real-time communications (RTC) remains a significant challenge, primarily due to the continuously evolving heterogeneous network architectures and technologies. From the first bandwidth estimation challenge which was hosted at ACM MMSys 2021, we learned that bandwidth estimation models trained with reinforcement learning (RL) in simulations to maximize network-based reward functions may not be optimal in reality due to the sim-to-real gap and the difficulty of aligning network-based rewards with user-perceived QoE. This grand challenge aims to advance bandwidth estimation model design by aligning reward maximization with user-perceived QoE optimization using offline RL and a real-world dataset with objective rewards which have high correlations with subjective audio/video quality in Microsoft Teams. All models submitted to the grand challenge underwent initial evaluation on our emulation platform. For a comprehensive evaluation under diverse network conditions with temporal fluctuations, top models were further evaluated on our geographically distributed testbed by using each model to conduct 600 calls within a 12-day period. The winning model is shown to deliver comparable performance to the top behavior policy in the released dataset. By leveraging real-world data and integrating objective audio/video quality scores as rewards, offline RL can therefore facilitate the development of competitive bandwidth estimators for RTC.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2024; v1 submitted 10 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Real-time Bandwidth Estimation from Offline Expert Demonstrations
Authors:
Aashish Gottipati,
Sami Khairy,
Gabriel Mittag,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler
Abstract:
In this work, we tackle the problem of bandwidth estimation (BWE) for real-time communication systems; however, in contrast to previous works, we leverage the vast efforts of prior heuristic-based BWE methods and synergize these approaches with deep learning-based techniques. Our work addresses challenges in generalizing to unseen network dynamics and extracting rich representations from prior exp…
▽ More
In this work, we tackle the problem of bandwidth estimation (BWE) for real-time communication systems; however, in contrast to previous works, we leverage the vast efforts of prior heuristic-based BWE methods and synergize these approaches with deep learning-based techniques. Our work addresses challenges in generalizing to unseen network dynamics and extracting rich representations from prior experience, two key challenges in integrating data-driven bandwidth estimators into real-time systems. To that end, we propose Merlin, the first purely offline, data-driven solution to BWE that harnesses prior heuristic-based methods to extract an expert BWE policy. Through a series of experiments, we demonstrate that Merlin surpasses state-of-the-art heuristic-based and deep learning-based bandwidth estimators in terms of objective quality of experience metrics while generalizing beyond the offline world to in-the-wild network deployments where Merlin achieves a 42.85% and 12.8% reduction in packet loss and delay, respectively, when compared against WebRTC in inter-continental videoconferencing calls. We hope that Merlin's offline-oriented design fosters new strategies for real-time network control.
△ Less
Submitted 23 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
A Real-Time Active Speaker Detection System Integrating an Audio-Visual Signal with a Spatial Querying Mechanism
Authors:
Ilya Gurvich,
Ido Leichter,
Dharmendar Reddy Palle,
Yossi Asher,
Alon Vinnikov,
Igor Abramovski,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler,
Eyal Krupka
Abstract:
We introduce a distinctive real-time, causal, neural network-based active speaker detection system optimized for low-power edge computing. This system drives a virtual cinematography module and is deployed on a commercial device. The system uses data originating from a microphone array and a 360-degree camera. Our network requires only 127 MFLOPs per participant, for a meeting with 14 participants…
▽ More
We introduce a distinctive real-time, causal, neural network-based active speaker detection system optimized for low-power edge computing. This system drives a virtual cinematography module and is deployed on a commercial device. The system uses data originating from a microphone array and a 360-degree camera. Our network requires only 127 MFLOPs per participant, for a meeting with 14 participants. Unlike previous work, we examine the error rate of our network when the computational budget is exhausted, and find that it exhibits graceful degradation, allowing the system to operate reasonably well even in this case. Departing from conventional DOA estimation approaches, our network learns to query the available acoustic data, considering the detected head locations. We train and evaluate our algorithm on a realistic meetings dataset featuring up to 14 participants in the same meeting, overlapped speech, and other challenging scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
LSTM-based Video Quality Prediction Accounting for Temporal Distortions in Videoconferencing Calls
Authors:
Gabriel Mittag,
Babak Naderi,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler
Abstract:
Current state-of-the-art video quality models, such as VMAF, give excellent prediction results by comparing the degraded video with its reference video. However, they do not consider temporal distortions (e.g., frame freezes or skips) that occur during videoconferencing calls. In this paper, we present a data-driven approach for modeling such distortions automatically by training an LSTM with subj…
▽ More
Current state-of-the-art video quality models, such as VMAF, give excellent prediction results by comparing the degraded video with its reference video. However, they do not consider temporal distortions (e.g., frame freezes or skips) that occur during videoconferencing calls. In this paper, we present a data-driven approach for modeling such distortions automatically by training an LSTM with subjective quality ratings labeled via crowdsourcing. The videos were collected from live videoconferencing calls in 83 different network conditions. We applied QR codes as markers on the source videos to create aligned references and compute temporal features based on the alignment vectors. Using these features together with VMAF core features, our proposed model achieves a PCC of 0.99 on the validation set. Furthermore, our model outputs per-frame quality that gives detailed insight into the cause of video quality impairments. The VCM model and dataset are open-sourced at https://github.com/microsoft/Video_Call_MOS.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
ICASSP 2023 Deep Noise Suppression Challenge
Authors:
Harishchandra Dubey,
Ashkan Aazami,
Vishak Gopal,
Babak Naderi,
Sebastian Braun,
Ross Cutler,
Alex Ju,
Mehdi Zohourian,
Min Tang,
Hannes Gamper,
Mehrsa Golestaneh,
Robert Aichner
Abstract:
Deep Speech Enhancement Challenge is the 5th edition of deep noise suppression (DNS) challenges organized at ICASSP 2023 Signal Processing Grand Challenges. DNS challenges were organized during 2019-2023 to stimulate research in deep speech enhancement (DSE). Previous DNS challenges were organized at INTERSPEECH 2020, ICASSP 2021, INTERSPEECH 2021, and ICASSP 2022. From prior editions, we learnt t…
▽ More
Deep Speech Enhancement Challenge is the 5th edition of deep noise suppression (DNS) challenges organized at ICASSP 2023 Signal Processing Grand Challenges. DNS challenges were organized during 2019-2023 to stimulate research in deep speech enhancement (DSE). Previous DNS challenges were organized at INTERSPEECH 2020, ICASSP 2021, INTERSPEECH 2021, and ICASSP 2022. From prior editions, we learnt that improving signal quality (SIG) is challenging particularly in presence of simultaneously active interfering talkers and noise. This challenge aims to develop models for joint denosing, dereverberation and suppression of interfering talkers. When primary talker wears a headphone, certain acoustic properties of their speech such as direct-to-reverberation (DRR), signal to noise ratio (SNR) etc. make it possible to suppress neighboring talkers even without enrollment data for primary talker. This motivated us to create two tracks for this challenge: (i) Track-1 Headset; (ii) Track-2 Speakerphone. Both tracks has fullband (48kHz) training data and testset, and each testclips has a corresponding enrollment data (10-30s duration) for primary talker. Each track invited submissions of personalized and non-personalized models all of which are evaluated through same subjective evaluation. Most models submitted to challenge were personalized models, same team is winner in both tracks where the best models has improvement of 0.145 and 0.141 in challenge's Score as compared to noisy blind testset.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2023; v1 submitted 20 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
ICASSP 2022 Deep Noise Suppression Challenge
Authors:
Harishchandra Dubey,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler,
Ashkan Aazami,
Sergiy Matusevych,
Sebastian Braun,
Sefik Emre Eskimez,
Manthan Thakker,
Takuya Yoshioka,
Hannes Gamper,
Robert Aichner
Abstract:
The Deep Noise Suppression (DNS) challenge is designed to foster innovation in the area of noise suppression to achieve superior perceptual speech quality. This is the 4th DNS challenge, with the previous editions held at INTERSPEECH 2020, ICASSP 2021, and INTERSPEECH 2021. We open-source datasets and test sets for researchers to train their deep noise suppression models, as well as a subjective e…
▽ More
The Deep Noise Suppression (DNS) challenge is designed to foster innovation in the area of noise suppression to achieve superior perceptual speech quality. This is the 4th DNS challenge, with the previous editions held at INTERSPEECH 2020, ICASSP 2021, and INTERSPEECH 2021. We open-source datasets and test sets for researchers to train their deep noise suppression models, as well as a subjective evaluation framework based on ITU-T P.835 to rate and rank-order the challenge entries. We provide access to DNSMOS P.835 and word accuracy (WAcc) APIs to challenge participants to help with iterative model improvements. In this challenge, we introduced the following changes: (i) Included mobile device scenarios in the blind test set; (ii) Included a personalized noise suppression track with baseline; (iii) Added WAcc as an objective metric; (iv) Included DNSMOS P.835; (v) Made the training datasets and test sets fullband (48 kHz). We use an average of WAcc and subjective scores P.835 SIG, BAK, and OVRL to get the final score for ranking the DNS models. We believe that as a research community, we still have a long way to go in achieving excellent speech quality in challenging noisy real-world scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Performance optimizations on deep noise suppression models
Authors:
Jerry Chee,
Sebastian Braun,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler
Abstract:
We study the role of magnitude structured pruning as an architecture search to speed up the inference time of a deep noise suppression (DNS) model. While deep learning approaches have been remarkably successful in enhancing audio quality, their increased complexity inhibits their deployment in real-time applications. We achieve up to a 7.25X inference speedup over the baseline, with a smooth model…
▽ More
We study the role of magnitude structured pruning as an architecture search to speed up the inference time of a deep noise suppression (DNS) model. While deep learning approaches have been remarkably successful in enhancing audio quality, their increased complexity inhibits their deployment in real-time applications. We achieve up to a 7.25X inference speedup over the baseline, with a smooth model performance degradation. Ablation studies indicate that our proposed network re-parameterization (i.e., size per layer) is the major driver of the speedup, and that magnitude structured pruning does comparably to directly training a model in the smaller size. We report inference speed because a parameter reduction does not necessitate speedup, and we measure model quality using an accurate non-intrusive objective speech quality metric.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
DNSMOS P.835: A Non-Intrusive Perceptual Objective Speech Quality Metric to Evaluate Noise Suppressors
Authors:
Chandan K A Reddy,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler
Abstract:
Human subjective evaluation is the gold standard to evaluate speech quality optimized for human perception. Perceptual objective metrics serve as a proxy for subjective scores. We have recently developed a non-intrusive speech quality metric called Deep Noise Suppression Mean Opinion Score (DNSMOS) using the scores from ITU-T Rec. P.808 subjective evaluation. The P.808 scores reflect the overall q…
▽ More
Human subjective evaluation is the gold standard to evaluate speech quality optimized for human perception. Perceptual objective metrics serve as a proxy for subjective scores. We have recently developed a non-intrusive speech quality metric called Deep Noise Suppression Mean Opinion Score (DNSMOS) using the scores from ITU-T Rec. P.808 subjective evaluation. The P.808 scores reflect the overall quality of the audio clip. ITU-T Rec. P.835 subjective evaluation framework gives the standalone quality scores of speech and background noise in addition to the overall quality. In this work, we train an objective metric based on P.835 human ratings that outputs 3 scores: i) speech quality (SIG), ii) background noise quality (BAK), and iii) the overall quality (OVRL) of the audio. The developed metric is highly correlated with human ratings, with a Pearson's Correlation Coefficient (PCC)=0.94 for SIG and PCC=0.98 for BAK and OVRL. This is the first non-intrusive P.835 predictor we are aware of. DNSMOS P.835 is made publicly available as an Azure service.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2022; v1 submitted 4 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Intel HEXL: Accelerating Homomorphic Encryption with Intel AVX512-IFMA52
Authors:
Fabian Boemer,
Sejun Kim,
Gelila Seifu,
Fillipe D. M. de Souza,
Vinodh Gopal
Abstract:
Modern implementations of homomorphic encryption (HE) rely heavily on polynomial arithmetic over a finite field. This is particularly true of the CKKS, BFV, and BGV HE schemes. Two of the biggest performance bottlenecks in HE primitives and applications are polynomial modular multiplication and the forward and inverse number-theoretic transform (NTT). Here, we introduce Intel Homomorphic Encryptio…
▽ More
Modern implementations of homomorphic encryption (HE) rely heavily on polynomial arithmetic over a finite field. This is particularly true of the CKKS, BFV, and BGV HE schemes. Two of the biggest performance bottlenecks in HE primitives and applications are polynomial modular multiplication and the forward and inverse number-theoretic transform (NTT). Here, we introduce Intel Homomorphic Encryption Acceleration Library (Intel HEXL), a C++ library which provides optimized implementations of polynomial arithmetic for Intel processors. Intel HEXL takes advantage of the recent Intel Advanced Vector Extensions 512 (Intel AVX512) instruction set to provide state-of-the-art implementations of the NTT and modular multiplication. On the forward and inverse NTT, Intel HEXL provides up to 7.2x and 6.7x speedup, respectively, over a native C++ implementation. Intel HEXL also provides up to 6.0x speedup on the element-wise vector-vector modular multiplication, and 1.7x speedup on the element-wise vector-scalar modular multiplication. Intel HEXL is available open-source at https://github.com/intel/hexl under the Apache 2.0 license and has been adopted by the Microsoft SEAL and PALISADE homomorphic encryption libraries.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2021; v1 submitted 30 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Interspeech 2021 Deep Noise Suppression Challenge
Authors:
Chandan K A Reddy,
Harishchandra Dubey,
Kazuhito Koishida,
Arun Nair,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler,
Sebastian Braun,
Hannes Gamper,
Robert Aichner,
Sriram Srinivasan
Abstract:
The Deep Noise Suppression (DNS) challenge is designed to foster innovation in the area of noise suppression to achieve superior perceptual speech quality. We recently organized a DNS challenge special session at INTERSPEECH and ICASSP 2020. We open-sourced training and test datasets for the wideband scenario. We also open-sourced a subjective evaluation framework based on ITU-T standard P.808, wh…
▽ More
The Deep Noise Suppression (DNS) challenge is designed to foster innovation in the area of noise suppression to achieve superior perceptual speech quality. We recently organized a DNS challenge special session at INTERSPEECH and ICASSP 2020. We open-sourced training and test datasets for the wideband scenario. We also open-sourced a subjective evaluation framework based on ITU-T standard P.808, which was also used to evaluate participants of the challenge. Many researchers from academia and industry made significant contributions to push the field forward, yet even the best noise suppressor was far from achieving superior speech quality in challenging scenarios. In this version of the challenge organized at INTERSPEECH 2021, we are expanding both our training and test datasets to accommodate full band scenarios. The two tracks in this challenge will focus on real-time denoising for (i) wide band, and(ii) full band scenarios. We are also making available a reliable non-intrusive objective speech quality metric called DNSMOS for the participants to use during their development phase.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2021; v1 submitted 6 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Resonance: Replacing Software Constants with Context-Aware Models in Real-time Communication
Authors:
Jayant Gupchup,
Ashkan Aazami,
Yaran Fan,
Senja Filipi,
Tom Finley,
Scott Inglis,
Marcus Asteborg,
Luke Caroll,
Rajan Chari,
Markus Cozowicz,
Vishak Gopal,
Vinod Prakash,
Sasikanth Bendapudi,
Jack Gerrits,
Eric Lau,
Huazhou Liu,
Marco Rossi,
Dima Slobodianyk,
Dmitri Birjukov,
Matty Cooper,
Nilesh Javar,
Dmitriy Perednya,
Sriram Srinivasan,
John Langford,
Ross Cutler
, et al. (1 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Large software systems tune hundreds of 'constants' to optimize their runtime performance. These values are commonly derived through intuition, lab tests, or A/B tests. A 'one-size-fits-all' approach is often sub-optimal as the best value depends on runtime context. In this paper, we provide an experimental approach to replace constants with learned contextual functions for Skype - a widely used r…
▽ More
Large software systems tune hundreds of 'constants' to optimize their runtime performance. These values are commonly derived through intuition, lab tests, or A/B tests. A 'one-size-fits-all' approach is often sub-optimal as the best value depends on runtime context. In this paper, we provide an experimental approach to replace constants with learned contextual functions for Skype - a widely used real-time communication (RTC) application. We present Resonance, a system based on contextual bandits (CB). We describe experiences from three real-world experiments: applying it to the audio, video, and transport components in Skype. We surface a unique and practical challenge of performing machine learning (ML) inference in large software systems written using encapsulation principles. Finally, we open-source FeatureBroker, a library to reduce the friction in adopting ML models in such development environments
△ Less
Submitted 22 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
DNSMOS: A Non-Intrusive Perceptual Objective Speech Quality metric to evaluate Noise Suppressors
Authors:
Chandan K A Reddy,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler
Abstract:
Human subjective evaluation is the gold standard to evaluate speech quality optimized for human perception. Perceptual objective metrics serve as a proxy for subjective scores. The conventional and widely used metrics require a reference clean speech signal, which is unavailable in real recordings. The no-reference approaches correlate poorly with human ratings and are not widely adopted in the re…
▽ More
Human subjective evaluation is the gold standard to evaluate speech quality optimized for human perception. Perceptual objective metrics serve as a proxy for subjective scores. The conventional and widely used metrics require a reference clean speech signal, which is unavailable in real recordings. The no-reference approaches correlate poorly with human ratings and are not widely adopted in the research community. One of the biggest use cases of these perceptual objective metrics is to evaluate noise suppression algorithms. This paper introduces a multi-stage self-teaching based perceptual objective metric that is designed to evaluate noise suppressors. The proposed method generalizes well in challenging test conditions with a high correlation to human ratings.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2021; v1 submitted 28 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Lumos: A Library for Diagnosing Metric Regressions in Web-Scale Applications
Authors:
Jamie Pool,
Ebrahim Beyrami,
Vishak Gopal,
Ashkan Aazami,
Jayant Gupchup,
Jeff Rowland,
Binlong Li,
Pritesh Kanani,
Ross Cutler,
Johannes Gehrke
Abstract:
Web-scale applications can ship code on a daily to weekly cadence. These applications rely on online metrics to monitor the health of new releases. Regressions in metric values need to be detected and diagnosed as early as possible to reduce the disruption to users and product owners. Regressions in metrics can surface due to a variety of reasons: genuine product regressions, changes in user popul…
▽ More
Web-scale applications can ship code on a daily to weekly cadence. These applications rely on online metrics to monitor the health of new releases. Regressions in metric values need to be detected and diagnosed as early as possible to reduce the disruption to users and product owners. Regressions in metrics can surface due to a variety of reasons: genuine product regressions, changes in user population, and bias due to telemetry loss (or processing) are among the common causes. Diagnosing the cause of these metric regressions is costly for engineering teams as they need to invest time in finding the root cause of the issue as soon as possible. We present Lumos, a Python library built using the principles of AB testing to systematically diagnose metric regressions to automate such analysis. Lumos has been deployed across the component teams in Microsoft's Real-Time Communication applications Skype and Microsoft Teams. It has enabled engineering teams to detect 100s of real changes in metrics and reject 1000s of false alarms detected by anomaly detectors. The application of Lumos has resulted in freeing up as much as 95% of the time allocated to metric-based investigations. In this work, we open source Lumos and present our results from applying it to two different components within the RTC group over millions of sessions. This general library can be coupled with any production system to manage the volume of alerting efficiently.
△ Less
Submitted 23 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
The INTERSPEECH 2020 Deep Noise Suppression Challenge: Datasets, Subjective Testing Framework, and Challenge Results
Authors:
Chandan K. A. Reddy,
Vishak Gopal,
Ross Cutler,
Ebrahim Beyrami,
Roger Cheng,
Harishchandra Dubey,
Sergiy Matusevych,
Robert Aichner,
Ashkan Aazami,
Sebastian Braun,
Puneet Rana,
Sriram Srinivasan,
Johannes Gehrke
Abstract:
The INTERSPEECH 2020 Deep Noise Suppression (DNS) Challenge is intended to promote collaborative research in real-time single-channel Speech Enhancement aimed to maximize the subjective (perceptual) quality of the enhanced speech. A typical approach to evaluate the noise suppression methods is to use objective metrics on the test set obtained by splitting the original dataset. While the performanc…
▽ More
The INTERSPEECH 2020 Deep Noise Suppression (DNS) Challenge is intended to promote collaborative research in real-time single-channel Speech Enhancement aimed to maximize the subjective (perceptual) quality of the enhanced speech. A typical approach to evaluate the noise suppression methods is to use objective metrics on the test set obtained by splitting the original dataset. While the performance is good on the synthetic test set, often the model performance degrades significantly on real recordings. Also, most of the conventional objective metrics do not correlate well with subjective tests and lab subjective tests are not scalable for a large test set. In this challenge, we open-sourced a large clean speech and noise corpus for training the noise suppression models and a representative test set to real-world scenarios consisting of both synthetic and real recordings. We also open-sourced an online subjective test framework based on ITU-T P.808 for researchers to reliably test their developments. We evaluated the results using P.808 on a blind test set. The results and the key learnings from the challenge are discussed. The datasets and scripts can be found here for quick access https://github.com/microsoft/DNS-Challenge.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2020; v1 submitted 16 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
The INTERSPEECH 2020 Deep Noise Suppression Challenge: Datasets, Subjective Speech Quality and Testing Framework
Authors:
Chandan K. A. Reddy,
Ebrahim Beyrami,
Harishchandra Dubey,
Vishak Gopal,
Roger Cheng,
Ross Cutler,
Sergiy Matusevych,
Robert Aichner,
Ashkan Aazami,
Sebastian Braun,
Puneet Rana,
Sriram Srinivasan,
Johannes Gehrke
Abstract:
The INTERSPEECH 2020 Deep Noise Suppression Challenge is intended to promote collaborative research in real-time single-channel Speech Enhancement aimed to maximize the subjective (perceptual) quality of the enhanced speech. A typical approach to evaluate the noise suppression methods is to use objective metrics on the test set obtained by splitting the original dataset. Many publications report r…
▽ More
The INTERSPEECH 2020 Deep Noise Suppression Challenge is intended to promote collaborative research in real-time single-channel Speech Enhancement aimed to maximize the subjective (perceptual) quality of the enhanced speech. A typical approach to evaluate the noise suppression methods is to use objective metrics on the test set obtained by splitting the original dataset. Many publications report reasonable performance on the synthetic test set drawn from the same distribution as that of the training set. However, often the model performance degrades significantly on real recordings. Also, most of the conventional objective metrics do not correlate well with subjective tests and lab subjective tests are not scalable for a large test set. In this challenge, we open-source a large clean speech and noise corpus for training the noise suppression models and a representative test set to real-world scenarios consisting of both synthetic and real recordings. We also open source an online subjective test framework based on ITU-T P.808 for researchers to quickly test their developments. The winners of this challenge will be selected based on subjective evaluation on a representative test set using P.808 framework.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2020; v1 submitted 23 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.