-
Automated Security Findings Management: A Case Study in Industrial DevOps
Authors:
Markus Voggenreiter,
Florian Angermeir,
Fabiola Moyón,
Ulrich Schöpp,
Pierre Bonvin
Abstract:
In recent years, DevOps, the unification of development and operation workflows, has become a trend for the industrial software development lifecycle. Security activities turned into an essential field of application for DevOps principles as they are a fundamental part of secure software development in the industry. A common practice arising from this trend is the automation of security tests that…
▽ More
In recent years, DevOps, the unification of development and operation workflows, has become a trend for the industrial software development lifecycle. Security activities turned into an essential field of application for DevOps principles as they are a fundamental part of secure software development in the industry. A common practice arising from this trend is the automation of security tests that analyze a software product from several perspectives. To effectively improve the security of the analyzed product, the identified security findings must be managed and looped back to the project team for stakeholders to take action. This management must cope with several challenges ranging from low data quality to a consistent prioritization of findings while following DevOps aims. To manage security findings with the same efficiency as other activities in DevOps projects, a methodology for the management of industrial security findings minding DevOps principles is essential.
In this paper, we propose a methodology for the management of security findings in industrial DevOps projects, summarizing our research in this domain and presenting the resulting artifact. As an instance of the methodology, we developed the Security Flama, a semantic knowledge base for the automated management of security findings. To analyze the impact of our methodology on industrial practice, we performed a case study on two DevOps projects of a multinational industrial enterprise. The results emphasize the importance of using such an automated methodology in industrial DevOps projects, confirm our approach's usefulness and positive impact on the studied projects, and identify the communication strategy as a crucial factor for usability in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Industrial Challenges in Secure Continuous Development
Authors:
Fabiola Moyón,
Florian Angermeir,
Daniel Mendez
Abstract:
The intersection between security and continuous software engineering has been of great interest since the early years of the agile development movement, and it remains relevant as software development processes are more frequently guided by agility and the adoption of DevOps. Several authors have contributed studies about the framing of secure agile development and secure DevOps, motivating acade…
▽ More
The intersection between security and continuous software engineering has been of great interest since the early years of the agile development movement, and it remains relevant as software development processes are more frequently guided by agility and the adoption of DevOps. Several authors have contributed studies about the framing of secure agile development and secure DevOps, motivating academic contributions to methods and practices, but also discussions around benefits and challenges. Especially the challenges captured also our interest since, for the last few years, we are conducting research on secure continuous software engineering from a more applied, practical perspective with the overarching aim to introduce solutions that can be adopted at scale. The short positioning at hands summarizes a relevant part of our endeavors in which we validated challenges with several practitioners of different roles. More than framing a set of challenges, we conclude by presenting four key research directions we identified for practitioners and researchers to delineate future work.
△ Less
Submitted 12 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Using Process Models to understand Security Standards
Authors:
Fabiola Moyón,
Daniel Méndez,
Kristian Beckers,
Sebastian Klepper
Abstract:
Many industrial software development processes today have to comply with security standards such as the IEC~62443-4-1. These standards, written in natural language, are ambiguous and complex to understand. This is especially true for non-security experts. Security practitioners thus invest much effort into comprehending standards and, later, into introducing them to development teams. However, our…
▽ More
Many industrial software development processes today have to comply with security standards such as the IEC~62443-4-1. These standards, written in natural language, are ambiguous and complex to understand. This is especially true for non-security experts. Security practitioners thus invest much effort into comprehending standards and, later, into introducing them to development teams. However, our experience in the industry shows that development practitioners might very well also read such standards, but nevertheless end up inviting experts for interpretation (or confirmation). Such a scenario is not in tune with current trends and needs of increasing velocity in continuous software engineering.
In this paper, we propose a tool-supported approach to make security standards more precise and easier to understand for both non-security as well as security experts by applying process models. This approach emerges from a large industrial company and encompasses so far the IEC62443-4-1 standard. We further present a case study with 16 industry practitioners showing how the approach improves communication between development and security compliance practitioners.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
How to Integrate Security Compliance Requirements with Agile Software Engineering at Scale?
Authors:
Fabiola Moyón,
Daniel Méndez Fernández,
Kristian Beckers,
Sebastian Klepper
Abstract:
Integrating security into agile software development is an open issue for research and practice. Especially in strongly regulated industries, complexity increases not only when scaling agile practices but also when aiming for compliance with security standards. To achieve security compliance in a large-scale agile context, we developed S2C-SAFe: An extension of the Scaled Agile Framework that is c…
▽ More
Integrating security into agile software development is an open issue for research and practice. Especially in strongly regulated industries, complexity increases not only when scaling agile practices but also when aiming for compliance with security standards. To achieve security compliance in a large-scale agile context, we developed S2C-SAFe: An extension of the Scaled Agile Framework that is compliant to the security standard IEC~62443-4-1 for secure product development.
In this paper, we present the framework and its evaluation by agile and security experts within Siemens' large-scale project ecosystem. We discuss benefits and limitations as well as challenges from a practitioners' perspective. Our results indicate that \ssafe contributes to successfully integrating security compliance with lean and agile development in regulated environments. We also hope to raise awareness for the importance and challenges of integrating security in the scope of Continuous Software Engineering.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Integration of Security Standards in DevOps Pipelines: An Industry Case Study
Authors:
Fabiola Moyón Constante,
Rafael Soares,
Maria Pinto-Albuquerque,
Daniel Méndez,
Kristian Beckers
Abstract:
In the last decade, companies adopted DevOps as a fast path to deliver software products according to customer expectations, with well aligned teams and in continuous cycles. As a basic practice, DevOps relies on pipelines that simulate factory swim-lanes. The more automation in the pipeline, the shorter a lead time is supposed to be. However, applying DevOps is challenging, particularly for indus…
▽ More
In the last decade, companies adopted DevOps as a fast path to deliver software products according to customer expectations, with well aligned teams and in continuous cycles. As a basic practice, DevOps relies on pipelines that simulate factory swim-lanes. The more automation in the pipeline, the shorter a lead time is supposed to be. However, applying DevOps is challenging, particularly for industrial control systems (ICS) that support critical infrastructures and that must obey to rigorous requirements from security regulations and standards. Current research on security compliant DevOps presents open gaps for this particular domain and in general for systematic application of security standards. In this paper, we present a systematic approach to integrate standard-based security activities into DevOps pipelines and highlight their automation potential. Our intention is to share our experiences and help practitioners to overcome the trade-off between adding security activities into the development process and keeping a short lead time. We conducted an evaluation of our approach at a large industrial company considering the IEC 62443-4-1 security standard that regulates ICS. The results strengthen our confidence in the usefulness of our approach and artefacts, and in that they can support practitioners to achieve security compliance while preserving agility including short lead times.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Enterprise-Driven Open Source Software: A Case Study on Security Automation
Authors:
Florian Angermeir,
Markus Voggenreiter,
Fabiola Moyón,
Daniel Mendez
Abstract:
Agile and DevOps are widely adopted by the industry. Hence, integrating security activities with industrial practices, such as continuous integration (CI) pipelines, is necessary to detect security flaws and adhere to regulators' demands early. In this paper, we analyze automated security activities in CI pipelines of enterprise-driven open source software (OSS). This shall allow us, in the long-r…
▽ More
Agile and DevOps are widely adopted by the industry. Hence, integrating security activities with industrial practices, such as continuous integration (CI) pipelines, is necessary to detect security flaws and adhere to regulators' demands early. In this paper, we analyze automated security activities in CI pipelines of enterprise-driven open source software (OSS). This shall allow us, in the long-run, to better understand the extent to which security activities are (or should be) part of automated pipelines. In particular, we mine publicly available OSS repositories and survey a sample of project maintainers to better understand the role that security activities and their related tools play in their CI pipelines. To increase transparency and allow other researchers to replicate our study (and to take different perspectives), we further disclose our research artefacts. Our results indicate that security activities in enterprise-driven OSS projects are scarce and protection coverage is rather low. Only 6.83% of the analyzed 8,243 projects apply security automation in their CI pipelines, even though maintainers consider security to be rather important. This alerts industry to keep the focus on vulnerabilities of 3rd Party software and it opens space for other improvements of practice which we outline in this manuscript.
△ Less
Submitted 10 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
