-
Answering real-world clinical questions using large language model based systems
Authors:
Yen Sia Low,
Michael L. Jackson,
Rebecca J. Hyde,
Robert E. Brown,
Neil M. Sanghavi,
Julian D. Baldwin,
C. William Pike,
Jananee Muralidharan,
Gavin Hui,
Natasha Alexander,
Hadeel Hassan,
Rahul V. Nene,
Morgan Pike,
Courtney J. Pokrzywa,
Shivam Vedak,
Adam Paul Yan,
Dong-han Yao,
Amy R. Zipursky,
Christina Dinh,
Philip Ballentine,
Dan C. Derieg,
Vladimir Polony,
Rehan N. Chawdry,
Jordan Davies,
Brigham B. Hyde
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Evidence to guide healthcare decisions is often limited by a lack of relevant and trustworthy literature as well as difficulty in contextualizing existing research for a specific patient. Large language models (LLMs) could potentially address both challenges by either summarizing published literature or generating new studies based on real-world data (RWD). We evaluated the ability of five LLM-bas…
▽ More
Evidence to guide healthcare decisions is often limited by a lack of relevant and trustworthy literature as well as difficulty in contextualizing existing research for a specific patient. Large language models (LLMs) could potentially address both challenges by either summarizing published literature or generating new studies based on real-world data (RWD). We evaluated the ability of five LLM-based systems in answering 50 clinical questions and had nine independent physicians review the responses for relevance, reliability, and actionability. As it stands, general-purpose LLMs (ChatGPT-4, Claude 3 Opus, Gemini Pro 1.5) rarely produced answers that were deemed relevant and evidence-based (2% - 10%). In contrast, retrieval augmented generation (RAG)-based and agentic LLM systems produced relevant and evidence-based answers for 24% (OpenEvidence) to 58% (ChatRWD) of questions. Only the agentic ChatRWD was able to answer novel questions compared to other LLMs (65% vs. 0-9%). These results suggest that while general-purpose LLMs should not be used as-is, a purpose-built system for evidence summarization based on RAG and one for generating novel evidence working synergistically would improve availability of pertinent evidence for patient care.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2024;
originally announced July 2024.
-
ATCON: Attention Consistency for Vision Models
Authors:
Ali Mirzazadeh,
Florian Dubost,
Maxwell Pike,
Krish Maniar,
Max Zuo,
Christopher Lee-Messer,
Daniel Rubin
Abstract:
Attention--or attribution--maps methods are methods designed to highlight regions of the model's input that were discriminative for its predictions. However, different attention maps methods can highlight different regions of the input, with sometimes contradictory explanations for a prediction. This effect is exacerbated when the training set is small. This indicates that either the model learned…
▽ More
Attention--or attribution--maps methods are methods designed to highlight regions of the model's input that were discriminative for its predictions. However, different attention maps methods can highlight different regions of the input, with sometimes contradictory explanations for a prediction. This effect is exacerbated when the training set is small. This indicates that either the model learned incorrect representations or that the attention maps methods did not accurately estimate the model's representations. We propose an unsupervised fine-tuning method that optimizes the consistency of attention maps and show that it improves both classification performance and the quality of attention maps. We propose an implementation for two state-of-the-art attention computation methods, Grad-CAM and Guided Backpropagation, which relies on an input masking technique. We also show results on Grad-CAM and Integrated Gradients in an ablation study. We evaluate this method on our own dataset of event detection in continuous video recordings of hospital patients aggregated and curated for this work. As a sanity check, we also evaluate the proposed method on PASCAL VOC and SVHN. With the proposed method, with small training sets, we achieve a 6.6 points lift of F1 score over the baselines on our video dataset, a 2.9 point lift of F1 score on PASCAL, and a 1.8 points lift of mean Intersection over Union over Grad-CAM for weakly supervised detection on PASCAL. Those improved attention maps may help clinicians better understand vision model predictions and ease the deployment of machine learning systems into clinical care. We share part of the code for this article at the following repository: https://github.com/alimirzazadeh/SemisupervisedAttention.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Double Descent Optimization Pattern and Aliasing: Caveats of Noisy Labels
Authors:
Florian Dubost,
Erin Hong,
Max Pike,
Siddharth Sharma,
Siyi Tang,
Nandita Bhaskhar,
Christopher Lee-Messer,
Daniel Rubin
Abstract:
Optimization plays a key role in the training of deep neural networks. Deciding when to stop training can have a substantial impact on the performance of the network during inference. Under certain conditions, the generalization error can display a double descent pattern during training: the learning curve is non-monotonic and seemingly diverges before converging again after additional epochs. Thi…
▽ More
Optimization plays a key role in the training of deep neural networks. Deciding when to stop training can have a substantial impact on the performance of the network during inference. Under certain conditions, the generalization error can display a double descent pattern during training: the learning curve is non-monotonic and seemingly diverges before converging again after additional epochs. This optimization pattern can lead to early stopping procedures to stop training before the second convergence and consequently select a suboptimal set of parameters for the network, with worse performance during inference. In this work, in addition to confirming that double descent occurs with small datasets and noisy labels as evidenced by others, we show that noisy labels must be present both in the training and generalization sets to observe a double descent pattern. We also show that the learning rate has an influence on double descent, and study how different optimizers and optimizer parameters influence the apparition of double descent. Finally, we show that increasing the learning rate can create an aliasing effect that masks the double descent pattern without suppressing it. We study this phenomenon through extensive experiments on variants of CIFAR-10 and show that they translate to a real world application: the forecast of seizure events in epileptic patients from continuous electroencephalographic recordings.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2021; v1 submitted 3 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.