-
A System for Human-Robot Teaming through End-User Programming and Shared Autonomy
Authors:
Michael Hagenow,
Emmanuel Senft,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Gleicher,
Michael Zinn,
Bilge Mutlu
Abstract:
Many industrial tasks-such as sanding, installing fasteners, and wire harnessing-are difficult to automate due to task complexity and variability. We instead investigate deploying robots in an assistive role for these tasks, where the robot assumes the physical task burden and the skilled worker provides both the high-level task planning and low-level feedback necessary to effectively complete the…
▽ More
Many industrial tasks-such as sanding, installing fasteners, and wire harnessing-are difficult to automate due to task complexity and variability. We instead investigate deploying robots in an assistive role for these tasks, where the robot assumes the physical task burden and the skilled worker provides both the high-level task planning and low-level feedback necessary to effectively complete the task. In this article, we describe the development of a system for flexible human-robot teaming that combines state-of-the-art methods in end-user programming and shared autonomy and its implementation in sanding applications. We demonstrate the use of the system in two types of sanding tasks, situated in aircraft manufacturing, that highlight two potential workflows within the human-robot teaming setup. We conclude by discussing challenges and opportunities in human-robot teaming identified during the development, application, and demonstration of our system.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Handheld Haptic Device with Coupled Bidirectional Input
Authors:
Megh Vipul Doshi,
Michael Hagenow,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu,
Michael Zinn
Abstract:
Handheld kinesthetic haptic interfaces can provide greater mobility and richer tactile information as compared to traditional grounded devices. In this paper, we introduce a new handheld haptic interface which takes input using bidirectional coupled finger flexion. We present the device design motivation and design details and experimentally evaluate its performance in terms of transparency and re…
▽ More
Handheld kinesthetic haptic interfaces can provide greater mobility and richer tactile information as compared to traditional grounded devices. In this paper, we introduce a new handheld haptic interface which takes input using bidirectional coupled finger flexion. We present the device design motivation and design details and experimentally evaluate its performance in terms of transparency and rendering bandwidth using a handheld prototype device. In addition, we assess the device's functional performance through a user study comparing the proposed device to a commonly used grounded input device in a set of targeting and tracking tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Coordinated Multi-Robot Shared Autonomy Based on Scheduling and Demonstrations
Authors:
Michael Hagenow,
Emmanuel Senft,
Nitzan Orr,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu,
Dylan P. Losey,
Michael Zinn
Abstract:
Shared autonomy methods, where a human operator and a robot arm work together, have enabled robots to complete a range of complex and highly variable tasks. Existing work primarily focuses on one human sharing autonomy with a single robot. By contrast, in this paper we present an approach for multi-robot shared autonomy that enables one operator to provide real-time corrections across two coordina…
▽ More
Shared autonomy methods, where a human operator and a robot arm work together, have enabled robots to complete a range of complex and highly variable tasks. Existing work primarily focuses on one human sharing autonomy with a single robot. By contrast, in this paper we present an approach for multi-robot shared autonomy that enables one operator to provide real-time corrections across two coordinated robots completing the same task in parallel. Sharing autonomy with multiple robots presents fundamental challenges. The human can only correct one robot at a time, and without coordination, the human may be left idle for long periods of time. Accordingly, we develop an approach that aligns the robot's learned motions to best utilize the human's expertise. Our key idea is to leverage Learning from Demonstration (LfD) and time warping to schedule the motions of the robots based on when they may require assistance. Our method uses variability in operator demonstrations to identify the types of corrections an operator might apply during shared autonomy, leverages flexibility in how quickly the task was performed in demonstrations to aid in scheduling, and iteratively estimates the likelihood of when corrections may be needed to ensure that only one robot is completing an action requiring assistance. Through a preliminary study, we show that our method can decrease the scheduled time spent sanding by iteratively estimating the times when each robot could need assistance and generating an optimized schedule that allows the operator to provide corrections to each robot during these times.
△ Less
Submitted 25 October, 2023; v1 submitted 28 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
A Method For Automated Drone Viewpoints to Support Remote Robot Manipulation
Authors:
Emmanuel Senft,
Michael Hagenow,
Pragathi Praveena,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Zinn,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu
Abstract:
Drones can provide a minimally-constrained adapting camera view to support robot telemanipulation. Furthermore, the drone view can be automated to reduce the burden on the operator during teleoperation. However, existing approaches do not focus on two important aspects of using a drone as an automated view provider. The first is how the drone should select from a range of quality viewpoints within…
▽ More
Drones can provide a minimally-constrained adapting camera view to support robot telemanipulation. Furthermore, the drone view can be automated to reduce the burden on the operator during teleoperation. However, existing approaches do not focus on two important aspects of using a drone as an automated view provider. The first is how the drone should select from a range of quality viewpoints within the workspace (e.g., opposite sides of an object). The second is how to compensate for unavoidable drone pose uncertainty in determining the viewpoint. In this paper, we provide a nonlinear optimization method that yields effective and adaptive drone viewpoints for telemanipulation with an articulated manipulator. Our first key idea is to use sparse human-in-the-loop input to toggle between multiple automatically-generated drone viewpoints. Our second key idea is to introduce optimization objectives that maintain a view of the manipulator while considering drone uncertainty and the impact on viewpoint occlusion and environment collisions. We provide an instantiation of our drone viewpoint method within a drone-manipulator remote teleoperation system. Finally, we provide an initial validation of our method in tasks where we complete common household and industrial manipulations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Manually Acquiring Targets from Multiple Viewpoints Using Video Feedback
Authors:
Bailey Ramesh,
Anna Konstant,
Pragathi Praveena,
Emmanuel Senft,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu,
Michael Zinn,
Robert G. Radwin
Abstract:
Objective: The effect of camera viewpoint was studied when performing visually obstructed psychomotor targeting tasks. Background: Previous research in laparoscopy and robotic teleoperation found that complex perceptual-motor adaptations associated with misaligned viewpoints corresponded to degraded performance in manipulation. Because optimal camera positioning is often unavailable in restricted…
▽ More
Objective: The effect of camera viewpoint was studied when performing visually obstructed psychomotor targeting tasks. Background: Previous research in laparoscopy and robotic teleoperation found that complex perceptual-motor adaptations associated with misaligned viewpoints corresponded to degraded performance in manipulation. Because optimal camera positioning is often unavailable in restricted environments, alternative viewpoints that might mitigate performance effects are not obvious. Methods: A virtual keyboard-controlled targeting task was remotely distributed to workers of Amazon Mechanical Turk. The experiment was performed by 192 subjects for a static viewpoint with independent parameters of target direction, Fitts' law index of difficulty, viewpoint azimuthal angle (AA), and viewpoint polar angle (PA). A dynamic viewpoint experiment was also performed by 112 subjects in which the viewpoint AA changed after every trial. Results: AA and target direction had significant effects on performance for the static viewpoint experiment. Movement time and travel distance increased while AA increased until there was a discrete improvement in performance for 180°. Increasing AA from 225° to 315° linearly decreased movement time and distance. There were significant main effects of current AA and magnitude of transition for the dynamic viewpoint experiment. Orthogonal direction and no-change viewpoint transitions least affected performance. Conclusions: Viewpoint selection should aim to minimize associated rotations within the manipulation plane when performing targeting tasks whether implementing a static or dynamic viewing solution. Because PA rotations had negligible performance effects, PA adjustments may extend the space of viable viewpoints. Applications: These results can inform viewpoint-selection for visual feedback during psychomotor tasks.
△ Less
Submitted 15 April, 2022; v1 submitted 14 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Registering Articulated Objects With Human-in-the-loop Corrections
Authors:
Michael Hagenow,
Emmanuel Senft,
Evan Laske,
Kimberly Hambuchen,
Terrence Fong,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu,
Michael Zinn
Abstract:
Remotely programming robots to execute tasks often relies on registering objects of interest in the robot's environment. Frequently, these tasks involve articulating objects such as opening or closing a valve. However, existing human-in-the-loop methods for registering objects do not consider articulations and the corresponding impact to the geometry of the object, which can cause the methods to f…
▽ More
Remotely programming robots to execute tasks often relies on registering objects of interest in the robot's environment. Frequently, these tasks involve articulating objects such as opening or closing a valve. However, existing human-in-the-loop methods for registering objects do not consider articulations and the corresponding impact to the geometry of the object, which can cause the methods to fail. In this work, we present an approach where the registration system attempts to automatically determine the object model, pose, and articulation for user-selected points using nonlinear fitting and the iterative closest point algorithm. When the fitting is incorrect, the operator can iteratively intervene with corrections after which the system will refit the object. We present an implementation of our fitting procedure for one degree-of-freedom (DOF) objects with revolute joints and evaluate it with a user study that shows that it can improve user performance, in measures of time on task and task load, ease of use, and usefulness compared to a manual registration approach. We also present a situated example that integrates our method into an end-to-end system for articulating a remote valve.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2022; v1 submitted 11 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Affordance Template Registration via Human-in-the-loop Corrections
Authors:
Michael Hagenow,
Michael Zinn,
Terrence Fong,
Evan Laske,
Kimberly Hambuchen
Abstract:
Affordance Templates (ATs) are a method for parameterizing objects for autonomous robot manipulations. In this approach, instances of an object are registered by positioning a model in a 3D environment, which requires a large amount of user input. We instead propose a registration method which combines autonomy and user corrections. For selected objects, the system determines both the model and co…
▽ More
Affordance Templates (ATs) are a method for parameterizing objects for autonomous robot manipulations. In this approach, instances of an object are registered by positioning a model in a 3D environment, which requires a large amount of user input. We instead propose a registration method which combines autonomy and user corrections. For selected objects, the system determines both the model and corresponding pose autonomously. The user makes corrections only if the model or pose is incorrect. This method increases the level of autonomy compared to existing approaches which can reduce user input and time on task. In this paper, we present an overview of existing methods, a description of our method, preliminary results, and planned future work.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Task-Level Authoring for Remote Robot Teleoperation
Authors:
Emmanuel Senft,
Michael Hagenow,
Kevin Welsh,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Zinn,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu
Abstract:
Remote teleoperation of robots can broaden the reach of domain specialists across a wide range of industries such as home maintenance, health care, light manufacturing, and construction. However, current direct control methods are impractical, and existing tools for programming robot remotely have focused on users with significant robotic experience. Extending robot remote programming to end users…
▽ More
Remote teleoperation of robots can broaden the reach of domain specialists across a wide range of industries such as home maintenance, health care, light manufacturing, and construction. However, current direct control methods are impractical, and existing tools for programming robot remotely have focused on users with significant robotic experience. Extending robot remote programming to end users, i.e., users who are experts in a domain but novices in robotics, requires tools that balance the rich features necessary for complex teleoperation tasks with ease of use. The primary challenge to usability is that novice users are unable to specify complete and robust task plans to allow a robot to perform duties autonomously, particularly in highly variable environments. Our solution is to allow operators to specify shorter sequences of high-level commands, which we call task-level authoring, to create periods of variable robot autonomy. This approach allows inexperienced users to create robot behaviors in uncertain environments by interleaving exploration, specification of behaviors, and execution as separate steps. End users are able to break down the specification of tasks and adapt to the current needs of the interaction and environments, combining the reactivity of direct control to asynchronous operation. In this paper, we describe a prototype system contextualized in light manufacturing and its empirical validation in a user study where 18 participants with some programming experience were able to perform a variety of complex telemanipulation tasks with little training. Our results show that our approach allowed users to create flexible periods of autonomy and solve rich manipulation tasks. Furthermore, participants significantly preferred our system over comparative more direct interfaces, demonstrating the potential of our approach.
△ Less
Submitted 6 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Recognizing Orientation Slip in Human Demonstrations
Authors:
Michael Hagenow,
Bolun Zhang,
Bilge Mutlu,
Michael Gleicher,
Michael Zinn
Abstract:
Manipulations of a constrained object often use a non-rigid grasp that allows the object to rotate relative to the end effector. This orientation slip strategy is often present in natural human demonstrations, yet it is generally overlooked in methods to identify constraints from such demonstrations. In this paper, we present a method to model and recognize prehensile orientation slip in human dem…
▽ More
Manipulations of a constrained object often use a non-rigid grasp that allows the object to rotate relative to the end effector. This orientation slip strategy is often present in natural human demonstrations, yet it is generally overlooked in methods to identify constraints from such demonstrations. In this paper, we present a method to model and recognize prehensile orientation slip in human demonstrations of constrained interactions. Using only observations of an end effector, we can detect the type of constraint, parameters of the constraint, and orientation slip properties. Our method uses a novel hierarchical model selection method that is informed by multiple origins of physics-based evidence. A study with eight participants shows that orientation slip occurs in natural demonstrations and confirms that it can be detected by our method.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Situated Live Programming for Human-Robot Collaboration
Authors:
Emmanuel Senft,
Michael Hagenow,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Zinn,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu
Abstract:
We present situated live programming for human-robot collaboration, an approach that enables users with limited programming experience to program collaborative applications for human-robot interaction. Allowing end users, such as shop floor workers, to program collaborative robots themselves would make it easy to "retask" robots from one process to another, facilitating their adoption by small and…
▽ More
We present situated live programming for human-robot collaboration, an approach that enables users with limited programming experience to program collaborative applications for human-robot interaction. Allowing end users, such as shop floor workers, to program collaborative robots themselves would make it easy to "retask" robots from one process to another, facilitating their adoption by small and medium enterprises. Our approach builds on the paradigm of trigger-action programming (TAP) by allowing end users to create rich interactions through simple trigger-action pairings. It enables end users to iteratively create, edit, and refine a reactive robot program while executing partial programs. This live programming approach enables the user to utilize the task space and objects by incrementally specifying situated trigger-action pairs, substantially lowering the barrier to entry for programming or reprogramming robots for collaboration. We instantiate situated live programming in an authoring system where users can create trigger-action programs by annotating an augmented video feed from the robot's perspective and assign robot actions to trigger conditions. We evaluated this system in a study where participants (n = 10) developed robot programs for solving collaborative light-manufacturing tasks. Results showed that users with little programming experience were able to program HRC tasks in an interactive fashion and our situated live programming approach further supported individualized strategies and workflows. We conclude by discussing opportunities and limitations of the proposed approach, our system implementation, and our study and discuss a roadmap for expanding this approach to a broader range of tasks and applications.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Informing Real-time Corrections in Corrective Shared Autonomy Through Expert Demonstrations
Authors:
Michael Hagenow,
Emmanuel Senft,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu,
Michael Zinn
Abstract:
Corrective Shared Autonomy is a method where human corrections are layered on top of an otherwise autonomous robot behavior. Specifically, a Corrective Shared Autonomy system leverages an external controller to allow corrections across a range of task variables (e.g., spinning speed of a tool, applied force, path) to address the specific needs of a task. However, this inherent flexibility makes th…
▽ More
Corrective Shared Autonomy is a method where human corrections are layered on top of an otherwise autonomous robot behavior. Specifically, a Corrective Shared Autonomy system leverages an external controller to allow corrections across a range of task variables (e.g., spinning speed of a tool, applied force, path) to address the specific needs of a task. However, this inherent flexibility makes the choice of what corrections to allow at any given instant difficult to determine. This choice of corrections includes determining appropriate robot state variables, scaling for these variables, and a way to allow a user to specify the corrections in an intuitive manner. This paper enables efficient Corrective Shared Autonomy by providing an automated solution based on Learning from Demonstration to both extract the nominal behavior and address these core problems. Our evaluation shows that this solution enables users to successfully complete a surface cleaning task, identifies different strategies users employed in applying corrections, and points to future improvements for our solution.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Corrective Shared Autonomy for Addressing Task Variability
Authors:
Michael Hagenow,
Emmanuel Senft,
Robert Radwin,
Michael Gleicher,
Bilge Mutlu,
Michael Zinn
Abstract:
Many tasks, particularly those involving interaction with the environment, are characterized by high variability, making robotic autonomy difficult. One flexible solution is to introduce the input of a human with superior experience and cognitive abilities as part of a shared autonomy policy. However, current methods for shared autonomy are not designed to address the wide range of necessary corre…
▽ More
Many tasks, particularly those involving interaction with the environment, are characterized by high variability, making robotic autonomy difficult. One flexible solution is to introduce the input of a human with superior experience and cognitive abilities as part of a shared autonomy policy. However, current methods for shared autonomy are not designed to address the wide range of necessary corrections (e.g., positions, forces, execution rate, etc.) that the user may need to provide to address task variability. In this paper, we present corrective shared autonomy, where users provide corrections to key robot state variables on top of an otherwise autonomous task model. We provide an instantiation of this shared autonomy paradigm and demonstrate its viability and benefits such as low user effort and physical demand via a system-level user study on three tasks involving variability situated in aircraft manufacturing.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2021; v1 submitted 14 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
A Method for Constraint Inference Using Pose and Wrench Measurements
Authors:
Guru Subramani,
Michael Hagenow,
Michael Gleicher,
Michael Zinn
Abstract:
Many physical tasks such as pulling out a drawer or wiping a table can be modeled with geometric constraints. These geometric constraints are characterized by restrictions on kinematic trajectories and reaction wrenches (forces and moments) of objects under the influence of the constraint. This paper presents a method to infer geometric constraints involving unmodeled objects in human demonstratio…
▽ More
Many physical tasks such as pulling out a drawer or wiping a table can be modeled with geometric constraints. These geometric constraints are characterized by restrictions on kinematic trajectories and reaction wrenches (forces and moments) of objects under the influence of the constraint. This paper presents a method to infer geometric constraints involving unmodeled objects in human demonstrations using both kinematic and wrench measurements. Our approach takes a recording of a human demonstration and determines what constraints are present, when they occur, and their parameters (e.g. positions). By using both kinematic and wrench information, our methods are able to reliably identify a variety of constraint types, even if the constraints only exist for short durations within the demonstration. We present a systematic approach to fitting arbitrary scleronomic constraint models to kinematic and wrench measurements. Reaction forces are estimated from measurements by removing friction. Position, orientation, force, and moment error metrics are developed to provide systematic comparison between constraint models. By conducting a user study, we show that our methods can reliably identify constraints in realistic situations and confirm the value of including forces and moments in the model regression and selection process.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Development of a Real-time Indoor Location System using Bluetooth Low Energy Technology and Deep Learning to Facilitate Clinical Applications
Authors:
Guanglin Tang,
Yulong Yan,
Chenyang Shen,
Xun Jia,
Meyer Zinn,
Zipalkumar Trivedi,
Alicia Yingling,
Kenneth Westover,
Steve Jiang
Abstract:
An indoor, real-time location system (RTLS) can benefit both hospitals and patients by improving clinical efficiency through data-driven optimization of procedures. Bluetooth-based RTLS systems are cost-effective but lack accuracy and robustness because Bluetooth signal strength is subject to fluctuation. We developed a machine learning-based solution using a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) network…
▽ More
An indoor, real-time location system (RTLS) can benefit both hospitals and patients by improving clinical efficiency through data-driven optimization of procedures. Bluetooth-based RTLS systems are cost-effective but lack accuracy and robustness because Bluetooth signal strength is subject to fluctuation. We developed a machine learning-based solution using a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) network followed by a Multilayer Perceptron classifier and a posterior constraint algorithm to improve RTLS performance. Training and validation datasets showed that most machine learning models perform well in classifying individual location zones, although LSTM was most reliable. However, when faced with data indicating cross-zone trajectories, all models showed erratic zone switching. Thus, we implemented a history-based posterior constraint algorithm to reduce the variability in exchange for a slight decrease in responsiveness. This network increases robustness at the expense of latency. When latency is less of a concern, we computed the latency-corrected accuracy which is 100% for our testing data, significantly improved from LSTM without constraint which is 96.2%. The balance between robustness and responsiveness can be considered and adjusted on a case-by-case basis, according to the specific needs of downstream clinical applications. This system was deployed and validated in an academic medical center. Industry best practices enabled system scaling without substantial compromises to performance or cost.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2020; v1 submitted 24 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Deep Learning Development Environment in Virtual Reality
Authors:
Kevin C. VanHorn,
Meyer Zinn,
Murat Can Cobanoglu
Abstract:
Virtual reality (VR) offers immersive visualization and intuitive interaction. We leverage VR to enable any biomedical professional to deploy a deep learning (DL) model for image classification. While DL models can be powerful tools for data analysis, they are also challenging to understand and develop. To make deep learning more accessible and intuitive, we have built a virtual reality-based DL d…
▽ More
Virtual reality (VR) offers immersive visualization and intuitive interaction. We leverage VR to enable any biomedical professional to deploy a deep learning (DL) model for image classification. While DL models can be powerful tools for data analysis, they are also challenging to understand and develop. To make deep learning more accessible and intuitive, we have built a virtual reality-based DL development environment. Within our environment, the user can move tangible objects to construct a neural network only using their hands. Our software automatically translates these configurations into a trainable model and then reports its resulting accuracy on a test dataset in real-time. Furthermore, we have enriched the virtual objects with visualizations of the model's components such that users can achieve insight about the DL models that they are developing. With this approach, we bridge the gap between professionals in different fields of expertise while offering a novel perspective for model analysis and data interaction. We further suggest that techniques of development and visualization in deep learning can benefit by integrating virtual reality.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Inferring geometric constraints in human demonstrations
Authors:
Guru Subramani,
Michael Zinn,
Michael Gleicher
Abstract:
This paper presents an approach for inferring geometric constraints in human demonstrations. In our method, geometric constraint models are built to create representations of kinematic constraints such as fixed point, axial rotation, prismatic motion, planar motion and others across multiple degrees of freedom. Our method infers geometric constraints using both kinematic and force/torque informati…
▽ More
This paper presents an approach for inferring geometric constraints in human demonstrations. In our method, geometric constraint models are built to create representations of kinematic constraints such as fixed point, axial rotation, prismatic motion, planar motion and others across multiple degrees of freedom. Our method infers geometric constraints using both kinematic and force/torque information. The approach first fits all the constraint models using kinematic information and evaluates them individually using position, force and moment criteria. Our approach does not require information about the constraint type or contact geometry; it can determine both simultaneously. We present experimental evaluations using instrumented tongs that show how constraints can be robustly inferred in recordings of human demonstrations.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2018;
originally announced October 2018.
